Compare
Perpetory or Boldin: which one fits an owner whose income comes in lumps?
For an owner with irregular income, often both. Boldin is the better tool for the withdrawal years: tax sequencing, Social Security and RMDs. Perpetory handles the years before: it reads lumpy deposits from every company you own, takes out the money you only moved between your own accounts, and turns what's left into a savings pace and the year work becomes optional.
Last updated 2026-11-13
Which one is for you
| Your situation | The better fit |
|---|---|
| Your income is steady and you want Social Security and RMDs modeled | Boldin |
| Your income arrives in lumps, through more than one company | Perpetory, for the savings pace |
| Both of the above | Both: Perpetory for the pace, Boldin for the withdrawals |
The problem with a savings figure when income is irregular
A retirement plan needs to know what you save. On a salary that’s a number you can type: a share of every paycheck. An owner’s year looks different. A large distribution in March, nothing in the second quarter, then a payout from a second company in the fall.
Any single figure you enter for that year is a guess, and it’s a guess with a direction. The deposits you see in your personal account include money you moved from your own companies, which was already counted once as theirs. Add them up and you save more on paper than you do.
- What your tools add up, 12 mo
- $808,600
- Your own money, moved
- −$124,400
- What's actually yours
- $684,200
How Perpetory reads an irregular year
There’s no monthly savings field anywhere, because owners don’t save monthly. You log deposits when they happen, in whatever amount happened, and a quarter with nothing in it is a valid entry. The pace is calculated backwards into a year.
The figure underneath comes from the statements of every company you own and of your household, with transfers between your own accounts taken out of both sides. In the sample data that leaves $7,500 a month, and that’s the pace the Goal module projects from. When the business has a better year, the work-optional year moves with it.
What Boldin does better
The years after work stops. Perpetory doesn’t do any of these, and a dedicated planner does them well.
- Tax sequencing. Which account to draw from first, and when a Roth conversion pays off.
- Social Security and RMDs. When to claim, and the withdrawals the law requires later on.
- Linked accounts, if you want a live feed. Perpetory works from statement files and never asks for a bank login.
How they compare
| Capability | Perpetory | Retirement planners |
|---|---|---|
| Business and personal in one view | The whole point | Personal only |
| Multi-entity switching | Every view | No |
| Works without bank access | Never asks | Usually |
| Receivables and overdue tracking | Built in | No |
| Debt across all entities at once | Business + personal | No |
| Built-in analysis of your own figures | AI analyst | No |
| Operations feed the retirement plan | One click | Typed or synced |
| Deep US tax optimization | Not our job | Excellent |
Using both
Use Perpetory while you’re still building, to read your real pace from irregular income. Carry that pace into Boldin and use it for the drawdown: what to take out, in what order, and when to claim.
Questions owners ask
Is Perpetory a Boldin alternative for irregular income?
For the savings side, yes. Perpetory takes deposits when they happen, in whatever amount happened, and calculates your pace backwards into a year. For the withdrawal years, no: Boldin models tax sequencing, Social Security and RMDs, and Perpetory does none of that.
My income is lumpy. How does Perpetory turn it into a plan?
There's no monthly savings field, because owners don't save monthly. A quarter with nothing in it is a valid entry, a large distribution is counted once, and the pace comes from the free cash flow your companies actually produced, with transfers between your own accounts taken out.
Can I use Perpetory and Boldin together?
Yes. Use Perpetory for the years you're still building, to read your real pace and the year work becomes optional. Use Boldin for the drawdown: what to take out, in what order, and when to claim.
Does Perpetory link my bank accounts like Boldin does?
No, and there's no option to. You upload a CSV statement export when you choose. The trade is real: files instead of a live feed. In exchange, nothing holds standing access to your accounts.
See it on your own numbers
Perpetory is opening in small groups. Join the early-access list and you’ll get one email when your spot opens. Until then, the demo on the home page runs on a full year of sample data.