Compare
Perpetory or ProjectionLab: which one does an owner of several companies need?
Often both. ProjectionLab is the better tool for the withdrawal years: tax sequencing, Social Security and RMDs, none of which Perpetory does. What Perpetory adds is the figure a plan starts from, your savings pace, read from the free cash flow your companies actually produce, with transfers between your own accounts taken out.
Last updated 2026-11-13
Which one is for you
| Your situation | The better fit |
|---|---|
| You're paid a salary and want tax-aware withdrawal planning | ProjectionLab |
| You own several companies and pay yourself in irregular draws | Perpetory, for the savings pace |
| You own several companies and are close to the drawdown | Both: Perpetory for the pace, ProjectionLab for the withdrawals |
What a planner does better
Plainly: the years after work stops. Perpetory doesn’t do any of these, and a dedicated planner does them well.
- Tax sequencing. Which account to draw from first, and when a Roth conversion pays off.
- Social Security and RMDs. When to claim, and the withdrawals the law requires later on.
- The drawdown itself, modeled year by year once the paychecks have stopped.
Deep US tax optimization is the one row on our own comparison where we mark ourselves down, and that’s deliberate. It isn’t Perpetory’s job.
What Perpetory adds
Every plan starts from what you save. For someone on a salary that figure is easy. For an owner it’s the hard part: income arrives in irregular amounts, split across several companies and accounts, and part of what lands in your personal account is your own money, moved there from a company you own.
ProjectionLab can bring in real spending data, so you aren’t only typing numbers in. What syncing doesn’t settle is which money is new. A draw from your company arrives in your personal checking looking exactly like income, and it was already counted once, as the company’s.
Here is what that does to a year. Three companies and a household, twelve months of sample data:
- What your tools add up, 12 mo
- $808,600
- Your own money, moved
- −$124,400
- What's actually yours
- $684,200
The $124,400 is money moved between accounts the owner already had. Perpetory reads the statements of every company you own and of your household, takes out those transfers, and works out free cash flow across all of them. That’s your real pace, and it’s what the Goal module projects from.
How they compare
| Capability | Perpetory | Retirement planners |
|---|---|---|
| Business and personal in one view | The whole point | Personal only |
| Multi-entity switching | Every view | No |
| Works without bank access | Never asks | Usually |
| Receivables and overdue tracking | Built in | No |
| Debt across all entities at once | Business + personal | No |
| Built-in analysis of your own figures | AI analyst | No |
| Operations feed the retirement plan | One click | Typed or synced |
| Deep US tax optimization | Not our job | Excellent |
Using both
Use Perpetory for the years you’re still building: it tells you your pace and the age work becomes optional, and the date moves when the business does. Carry that pace into ProjectionLab as your savings and use it for the drawdown: how to take the money out, in what order, and when to claim. The two fit end to end.
See the Goal module on sample data →
Questions owners ask
Is Perpetory a ProjectionLab alternative for business owners?
For one part of the job. ProjectionLab is the better tool for the withdrawal years: tax sequencing, Social Security and RMDs. Perpetory works out the figure a plan starts from, your savings pace, from the statements of every company you own plus your household. Many owners would use both.
Can I use Perpetory and ProjectionLab together?
Yes, and they fit end to end. Perpetory reads your free cash flow across every entity and gives you a pace and a work-optional year. Carry that pace into ProjectionLab as your savings and let it plan the drawdown.
Why not just sync my accounts into the planner?
Because syncing brings in transactions, not which of them are new money. A draw from your company lands in personal checking looking exactly like income, though it was already counted once as the company's. Perpetory recognizes transfers between your own accounts and counts them once.
Does Perpetory do Roth conversions, Social Security or RMDs?
No. That's the one row of our own comparison where we mark ourselves down, deliberately. Perpetory is aimed at the twenty years before the drawdown.
See it on your own numbers
Perpetory is opening in small groups. Join the early-access list and you’ll get one email when your spot opens. Until then, the demo on the home page runs on a full year of sample data.